« السابقةمتابعة »
birds, fishes, and the smaller reptiles and mammalia which may be disposed of along the walls. The second description of cabinets will answer equally for shells, insects, rocks, minerals, and fossils. Thus every object for which a cabinet is likely to be required may find a place in one of the two sorts, to which it is proposed to confine the furniture of the Museum.
That an unnecessary variety in the form of cabinetsdestroys the uniformity of the Museum, and that lofty cabinets placed in the middle of the apartments, as at present, convey a sense of closeness and prevent the use of punkas, so essential in this climate, any one who has paid a visit to the Museum must see.
Indeed, without the strictest attention to some general plan in the fitting up of a Museum, it must appear to persons of taste rather as any thing rather than a place of science. Of all our cabinets, those only in which the perching birds have been placed on shelves by Mr. Jameson ought to be retained longer than it may be convenient to the Society to replace them. Twelve glazed tables of the pattern already alluded to, each nine feet in length, ought to be provided. These would admit of all the rocks and minerals, as well as fossils, which constitute an important portion of the Society's collection, being brought forward and exhibited. Even if twelve tables should prove too many for this object, the spare ones would be ready for the reception of such new collections of interest as might be sent to us in any of the numerous departments for which such tables are intended.
The next subject to consider is the nomenclature of the Museum. It is necessary, for various reasons, that this should not altogether rest on the authority of the Curator. There is a plan which with a little regularity in its execution, will place this very important object on the best possible footing, and at the same time afford to our Museum something more than local interest. Let every species be numbered, and all duplicates be numbered so as to correspond with the species to which they belong in the regular collection.* After retaining a perfect series or two let duplicates or triplicates be forwarded on the part of the Society to individuals eminent in particular branches of science, requesting that lists may be returned to the Society with the scientific names inserted opposite to the corresponding numbers, from such lists the names may then be transferred to the objects in the Museum. We should thus not only secure a perfect nomenclature, but at the same time disseminate a knowledge of the productions of India, and give a publicity to the contents of our collection far more important to the advancement of science than could be effected by any other means.
* There are now in the Museum some hundreds of duplicate skins of birds, some of which appear to have been intended for the East India Company's Museum; these
may be all numbered so as to correspond with our own collection, and figured lists transmitted with them to the India House, soliciting that such lists may be returned to the Society with the correct nomenclature inserted opposite to the figures. Anticipating no objection to this, I have already numbered most of the birds in the Society's collection, and have ordered corresponding numbers to be attached to those intended for the Honorable Court,
On the establishments of the Museum as they relate to expenditure, I am incompetent to offer any suggestions. It appears from the pecuniary accounts published in the January number of the Journal, that the Museum expenses in 1838 exceeded the Government grant of 200 Rupees per mensem by 1171 Rupees, although 246 Rupees only of that excess appears to be set down for cabinets. During the present year if the requisite cabinets be procured, and the other
of the Museum be continued as before, the excess beyond the Government grant for the support of the Museum, will necessarily amount to several thousand rupees.
The persons employed in the Museum at present are—two taxidermists, one on the receipt of 50 and the other 12 Rupees per mensem ; two carpenters at 8 Rupees each; and two native servants; whose salaries altogether amount to 88 Rupees per mensem.
The principal taxidermist cannot write, and as he is therefore incapable of keeping any record, it would be necessary to have some one else on the spot to wait on visitors, and assist in carrying on the business of the Museum. In the Library there is an assistant librarian who has been employed for several years on a salary of 30 Rupees a month, it would be necessary that his duties should be extended to the Museum, and that his salary should be raised, say from 30 to 50, or 60 Rupees a month, which would still leave a balance of 70 or 80 a month for petty expenses, so that the Government grant would thus just meet the current expenses of the Museum, exclusive of cabinets and Curator's salary.
If we have a Museum, we must have cabinets; the salary of a Curator is not however considered so essential, and some of the members of the Society have already protested against such an expenditure.
In proposing that the office should be an honorary one, I am guided entirely by what I conceive would be the sentiments of all votaries of science, without any affectation of disinterestedness on my own part. Indeed under any circumstances I could not undertake to hold the office of Curator longer than the plans here proposed should be placed in proper training, after which, the whole might be conducted by a subordinate establishment under the direction of the Committee of Papers ; a more efficient subordinate establishment might be provided for the Museum ; the increased value and extent of the collections seem to me to require more than two native servants, while the carpenters might be exchanged for collectors. If native collectors, on a monthly salary of 6 Rupees each be properly attended to and trained, they would soon put us in possession of most of the insects, fishes, and crustacea of Bengal, and all such persons, as well as those employed in the Museum, might be placed under the immediate direction of a well educated youth from one of the public schools. It would be necessary that such a person should be well recommended not only for general acquirements, but also for his taste in Natural History; the latter taste of course we could only expect to find in any youth from a Calcutta Seminary, on the non fit sed nascetur principle.
After providing all that is necessary in the way of cabinets, colleetors, and efficient establishments for conducting the duties of the Museum, if the funds of the Society should still allow of a specific sum being set apart for the remuneration of a Curator so much the better, although I must confess I should rather see him in circumstances that would render pecuniary remuneration from his colleagues unnecessary. As however it some times happens that science and fortune do not go hand in hand, a nominal salary of 30 Rupees a month might be azsigned to the office of Curator. It will be for the Committee of Finance to determine whether after providing for the increased expenses attending our augmented collections, a larger sum can consistently with the receipts of the Society be paid for the object in question.
From the above remarks we may deduce the following rules, which appear to embrace all that is necessary to secure the progressive advancement of the Museum :
1. The direction of the Museum to be entrusted to the Committee of
Papers, and its duties superintended by a scientific individual
appointed by the Society on the nomination of the Committee. 2. Although the office of Curator is held to be one of distinction, an
allowance of 30 Rupees per mensem is granted by the Society, to
be drawn or not according as the Curator may feel inclined. 3. That the subordinate establishments in the Museum shall consist, if
possible, of two well educated Europeans* or Natives of India, on
a salary of not less than 50 and 12 Rupees per month respectively. 4. That the number and occupation of other servants in the Museum
shall vary according to circumstances.
* This is not intended to interfere with the persons already employed in the Museum.
3. That only two descriptions of cabinets are to be admitted into the
Museum, namely, glass cases of one uniform pattern for the reception of birds, small quadrupeds and the like, which are to be placed along the walls; and, tables with glass covers of an uniform pattern for the reception of shells, insects, fossils requiring cabinets, geological specimens, and minerals; to be placed along
the centre of the apartments. 6. That all objects in the Museum be numbered and entered in Muse
um books to be provided for the purpose, and that duplicates of birds, shells, insects, and the like, be from time to time transmitted on the part of the Society, with figured lists, names of original donors, &c. to such eminent scientific individuals as may seem most likely to afford correct information regarding them, and who should be requested to return the lists with the names and refer
ences inserted opposite each figure or number. 7. That all such communications are to be regularly entered in Muse
um books, together with such replies as may be received on the subject.
June 4th, 1839.
Art. X.- Observations on the “ Report on the Museum of the Asiatic
Society, by Dr. WM. JAMESON,” published in the Journal for March, 1839. By J. T. PEARSON, Assistant Surgeon, formerly Curator of the Museum of the Asiatic Society.
To the Secretaries to the Asiatic Society. GENTLEMEN A paper by Dr. Wm. Jameson, entitled a “Report on the Museum of the Asiatic Society” having appeared in your Journal for March last, reached me to day; and as it appears to contain reflections upon my conduct while Curator of the Society's Museum ; and recommendations, which if I had not made I should have neglected, or been ignorant, of my duty; I request you will do me the favour to lay before the Society the following observations. I perceive you went out of your usual course to give the earliest publicity" to what you deem Dr. Jameson's “very important” paper; and, therefore, I trust you will do me the justice to publish my reply in the next number of your Journal.
Dr. Jameson begins by stating his disinclination to report upon the state of the Society's Museum, lest he might be considered as "attacking the proceedings of his predecessors." A very proper feeling, but
which, having overcome, he should not have allowed to retain such influence over his report, as to induce him to conceal the names of those, his predecessors, he thought fit to censure. For my part, I wish be had been more explicit, both for his own sake and for mine ; for hints and insinuations are difficult for me to deal with ; while they leave him open to a suspicion of being one of those who are
Willing to wound, and yet afraid to strike;" “Just hint a fault, and hesitate dislike"
a character, which I should be very sorry did I really think him to merit.
However lest I should be accused of appropriating to myself blame intended for another, conscious of deserving it; I must refer to what was said by Dr. M'Clelland (from whom of all men I least expected an attack) at a late meeting of the Society. Dr. Jameson might easily err from ignorance; Dr. M'Clelland could scarcely do so ;-the former possibly never heard much more of me than my name, still less the precise part I took in the management of the Museum ; the latter was aware I was one of those predecessors of Dr. Jameson he took precedence to censure* ; though, as he did not know the state of the collection of Natural History when I took charge (for I believe he had at that time never seen it) I know not how he can justify his bold comparison
Dr. Jameson first notices the “ minerals" and "rocks," and comments in severe terms upon the state in which he found, and left them. With this I have nothing to do. The mineralogical and geological (organic and inorganic) departments were never committed to my care. Mr. James Prinsep kept them in his own hands; and, in justice to him, I beg to say, that although from want of cabinets he could not arrange them ; there was, so far as I remember, none of that confusion and damage Dr. Jameson so forcibly bewails. Certainly they were packed in drawers, but they were well known to Mr. Prinsep. I believe most, if not all of consequence, of them, were labelled ; and the destruction spoken of is far more likely to have happened in their transmission to the Society, than in their quiet dormitories in the Society's rooms. At all events, as aforesaid, I had nothing to do with the mineralogy, nor geology either.t The zoology was my branch of the
* Sic. in M. S.--Eds.
+ I do not know the arrangements made with Mr. Evans; but I believe he had charge only of the zoological part of the Museum, and consequently was as innocent of the mismanagement (if any) of the minerals and rocks” as myself
. I think this due to an absent man. Lieut. Kittoe's proceedings I know still less of; but he, as well as the Museum Committee, are here to answer for themselves.